Checked against the book, live, every time.
Every structural check in the calculator is compared against published worked examples. The numbers below are computed by the engine running on this server, each time this page loads.
Rules
- Each value must be within 1% of the published value.
- A capacity may never exceed the published value beyond the published rounding. Any miss has to be on the safe side.
- An example is only used where the provision is unchanged between the example's code edition and the edition the engine implements; each source says which.
- Checks with no published example yet are listed below as not yet verified. The calculator marks them the same way.
AISC Design Examples v15.0 (companion to the Steel Construction Manual, 15th ed.)
secondary sourceOpen sourceValues as tabulated by AutoCalcs (AISC blocks automated download). Examples are keyed to AISC 360-16; F2, E3 and G2.1 are unchanged in 360-22. Shapes: AISC Shapes Database v15.0.
| Example | Provision | Quantity | Published | Engine | Diff | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AISC F.1-1B phiMn | F2.1 yielding | phiMn (kip-ft) | 379.0 | 378.8 | -0.07% | pass |
| AISC F.1-2B Lp | F2.2 limiting length | Lp (in) | 69.9 | 69.94 | +0.05% | pass |
| AISC F.1-2B Lr | F2.2 limiting length | Lr (in) | 203.0 | 203.3 | +0.17% | pass |
| AISC F.1-2B Mn | F2.2 inelastic LTB | Mn (kip-in) | 4060.0 | 4066 | +0.16% | pass |
| AISC F.1-2B phiMn | F2.2 inelastic LTB | phiMn (kip-ft) | 305.0 | 305 | -0.01% | pass |
| AISC F.1-3B Mn | F2.2 elastic LTB | Mn (kip-in) | 3840.0 | 3838 | -0.06% | pass |
| AISC F.1-3B phiMn | F2.2 elastic LTB | phiMn (kip-ft) | 288.0 | 287.8 | -0.06% | pass |
| AISC E.1C phiPn | E3 flexural buckling (weak axis) | phiPn (kip) | 892.0 | 893.2 | +0.13% | pass |
| AISC E.1D KL/r | E3 flexural buckling (strong axis) | KL/r | 58.6 | 58.63 | +0.05% | pass |
| AISC E.1D Fe | E3 flexural buckling (strong axis) | Fe (ksi) | 83.3 | 83.26 | -0.05% | pass |
| AISC E.1D Fcr | E3 flexural buckling (strong axis) | Fcr (ksi) | 38.9 | 38.89 | -0.03% | pass |
| AISC E.1D phiPn | E3 flexural buckling (strong axis) | phiPn (kip) | 927.0 | 927.5 | +0.05% | pass |
| AISC G.1B phiVn | G2.1 web shear (rolled I-shape) | phiVn (kip) | 306.0 | 305.7 | -0.09% | pass |
StructurePoint, Interaction Diagram - Tied Reinforced Concrete Column Design Strength (ACI 318-19), Table 1 (Wight, 8th ed., Example 11-1)
primary sourceOpen source16x16 in, f'c 5000 psi, fy 60 ksi, 8 #9, 2.5 in to bar centroid. Compared only where phi = 0.65.
| Example | Provision | Quantity | Published | Engine | Diff | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SP column phiPn,max | 22.4.2.1 maximum axial | phiPn,max (kip) | 797.7 | 797.7 | -0.00% | pass |
| SP column phiMn @ fs=0 | 22.2 / 22.4 interaction | phiMn (kip-ft) | 169.86 | 169.9 | -0.00% | pass |
| SP column phiMn @ fs=0.5fy | 22.2 / 22.4 interaction | phiMn (kip-ft) | 220.05 | 220.1 | +0.00% | pass |
| SP column phiMn @ balanced | 22.2 / 22.4 interaction | phiMn (kip-ft) | 250.77 | 249.8 | -0.40% | pass |
| SP column check D/C @ fs=0.5fy | check puts the published point on the curve | D/C | 1.0 | 1 | -0.00% | pass |
StructurePoint, Simply Supported Reinforced Concrete Beam Analysis and Design (ACI 318-14), version July-08-2025, sections 2 and 4.1, Table 2
primary sourceOpen sourceb 12 in, d 17.56 in, f'c 4350 psi, fy 60 ksi. Flexure (22.2, Table 22.2.2.4.3, 21.2.2) and As,min (9.6.1.2) are unchanged in 318-19; the example's one-way SHEAR is not used (changed in 318-19).
| Example | Provision | Quantity | Published | Engine | Diff | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SP beam As,min | 9.6.1.2 minimum flexural steel | As,min (in2) | 0.702 | 0.7024 | +0.06% | pass |
| SP beam a | 22.2.2 Whitney block depth | a (in) | 3.88 | 3.884 | +0.10% | pass |
| SP beam beta1 | Table 22.2.2.4.3 | beta1 | 0.83 | 0.8325 | +0.30% | pass |
| SP beam eps_t | 21.2.2 tension-controlled strain | eps_t | 0.0083 | 0.008292 | -0.09% | pass |
| SP beam phiMn = Mu | 22.2 flexural strength (phi 0.90) | phiMn (kip-ft) | 201.88 | 201.8 | -0.02% | pass |
| SP beam wu = 1.2D + 1.6L | basic combination 1.2D + 1.6L | wu (kip/ft) | 2.58 | 2.584 | +0.16% | pass |
Implemented but not yet verified against a published example
These exist in the engine but are not offered in the calculator until a published example covers them.
Verification shows the engine reproduces published examples; it is not an engineering opinion or a design. The engineer of record owns the design.